CCHA Study Sessions, 41(1974), 65-75
Reverend William Richard Harris, 1846-1923
by Robert J. SCOLLARD
The subject of this paper is the life and writings of Rev. William Richard Harris, priest of the Archdiocese of Toronto, who was born in Ireland on March 10, 1846, and who died in Toronto on March 5, 1923. Dean Harris, as he was widely known, was an outstanding parish priest, a well-travelled man, an author upon whom the University of Ottawa conferred an honorary doctorate, Nov. 12, 1896, the University of Toronto its LL.D., May 9, 1916, and L'Université Laval a D. ès L., Aug. 20, 1920. (1)
No full length biography of Harris has been published. One was written in 1924 by Thomas O'Hagan (1855-1939) for the Makers of Canadian Literature series but it was never printed. (2) An earlier manuscript life is no more than a list of the principal dates in his life down to 1890. (3) The first biographical sketch of Harris was published in 1888 and thereafter his name appeared regularly in works of collective biography. (4) It will be the purpose of this paper to correct inaccuracies in these notices and to fill the gaps in the story of his life using archival material, the reminiscences of friends who are still alive (5) and the glimpses of himself that Harris gives in his writings.
Harris seldom spoke about his family or himself. If the conversation turned on these topics he avoided a direct answer and in a humorous way made it clear that the subject should be changed. (6) When official requests for personal information compelled an answer he seems to have been careless in providing it. The first printed biographical notice gave the date of his birth as March 3, 1847, and the place as the City of Cork. (7) Two years later the manuscript biography of 1890, presumably also dependent upon information supplied by Harris gave the place simply as Cork, Ireland, and the date as March 10, 1847, adding that he came to Canada in the same year. (8) His name does not appear in the baptismal registers of the four parishes then within the City of Cork. (9) From the parish of Tracton in the Diocese of Cork, Rev. Richard Harris wrote that the name William Richard Harris intrigued him but it did not appear in his baptismal register. He suggested that his namesake, and Harris is a common name, might have been born in one of the other dioceses that are also in County Cork. (He mentioned that the name Harris was a Welsh name which meant son of Harry.) (10) Rev. Edward Kelly who was well acquainted with both Harris and his clerical friends used March 10, 1846, as the date of birth and gave the place simply as Cork, Ireland. (11) I am tentatively accepting this date.
Little is known about his family. His father's name was Richard (12) but his mother's name is not known. His Last Will mentioned a sister, Mrs. William Hickey and her husband living in Chicago and a grand niece, Frances O'Brien of Toronto. (13) An attempt has been made to link him with Mary Harris Jones (1830-1930), an American labor leader, but her biography gives 1835 as the year when her father came to the United States. (14)
Equally little is known about Harris' early life and education in Toronto. The Christian Brothers taught him in one of the Separate Schools. (15) Then he attended St. Michael's College as a day student and he was in 1865-66 a student for the priesthood who received financial help from the Diocese of Toronto. (16) From September 1867 to June 1869 he taught English at the Collège de Sainte-Anne-de-laPocatière, Quebec, and also studied theology. Bishop John Lynch (1816-1888) visited the College in May 1868 and on the 21st of that month admitted Harris to first tonsure. (17) During these years Harris grew to be a viking of a man, 6' 4" tall, with broad shoulders and the grace of an athlete. His strength was prodigious. His sports were handball, boxing (18) and rowing. (19)
Toronto was a missionary diocese in the 1860's and Bishop Lynch sent some of his students to the Propaganda College in Rome. Harris went there in the Fall of 1869, obtained the B.D. degree in 1870, and was ordained priest on June 11 of the same year by Cardinal Costantino Patrizzi (1798-1876)... (20) It is worth noting that Harris was in Rome during the First Vatican Council and enjoyed opportunities, not to be missed by his gregarious nature, of seeing bishops and priests from all over the world.
When Bishop Lynch was solemnly installed as first Archbishop of Toronto on September 11, 1870, Harris carried the pontifical insignia in the entrance procession and then celebrated Mass outdoors for those unable to gain admission to St. Michael's Cathedral. (21) Shortly afterwards he was appointed assistant to Rev. Timothy Sullivan (1842-1923) at St. James Parish, Colgan. Harris' name appears in the register of baptisms between Nov. 3, 1870, and Oct. 9, 1875. (22) The archives of the Archdiocese of Toronto mention a temporary appointment as assistant at St. Malachy's Parish, Brock Township, but the parish records there make no mention of his actually coming. (23) From Nov. 25, 1871, onwards Harris signed the Colgan registers as pastor. In this appointment he first showed himself to be a "building pastor" when he erected St. Mary's Church at Achill (West Adjala).
From Colgan Harris went to St. Michael's Cathedral, Toronto, where his name appears as rector in the baptismal register between Nov. 9, 1875, and Oct. 10, 1876. (24) Next he moved to the parish of St. John Chrysostom, Newmarket, where his name appears in the baptismal register between Oct. 15, 1876, and June 22, 1884. (25) Here he completed the church, built a rectory and a school. For his successor, Rev. Patrick Whitney (1843-1918) he left a note informing him of the ordinary revenues of the parish and also setting forth his personal views on raising money for parish needs:
Experience has convinced me that it is not - religiously speaking - wise policy to harass people with appeals for aid for small repairs, etc. Square dealing on the part of the priest towards his people gives him a great leverage. On a money basis we are all equal. (26)
Harris' last parochial appointment was to St. Catharine's Parish, St. Catharines, Ontario, where his name appears in the baptismal register between July 6, 1884, and June 2, 1901. He went there as administrator, then was appointed pastor and Dean of Niagara Peninsula on Dec. 17, 1884. (27) In St. Catharines he continued his building activities, opening new schools, enlarging and improving the church. The financial policy he enunciated at Newmarket was developed and led him to publish a "Statement of Receipts and Expenditures for St. Catharine's Parish, from Jan. 1st, 1885, to Dec. 31st 1888." In reporting this the Catholic Weekly Review observed:
The happy results which have flowed from his generous confidence in his people, first in the method in which he sought their co-operation, and now in the publication of this Statement would seem to argue for a more general adoption of the plan. (28)
In St. Catharines Harris worked to promote Christian good will but when Rev. George Burson (1833?-1895) attacked the Catholic religion in th local Orange Hall, Harris replied on the following Sunday night in his own church. He ended his sermon by saying he would
leave to the members of Knox Church and the public at large to judge the wisdom or expediency of a minister of the gospel of Christ scattering in the furrow of society the seeds of religious rancour and bitterness that might some day ripen into a hatred from which there would be reaped a harvest of barren regrets. (29)
He also strove to smooth out private difficulties arising from religious differences. Shortly after his arrival in St. Catharines he wrote to Colonel Charles Clarke (1826-1909), Speaker of the Ontario Legislature, in support of the application of David Boyle (1842-1911) for a position. The appointment was being held up possibly because
In conversation with the Honble Mr. Ross, I was given to understand that he was of the opinion that Mr. Boyle was an agnostic. (30)
I do not know if Boyle was or was not an agnostic but he did enter the government service and became director of the Ontario Provincial Museum which published each year an Archaeological Report. Friendship with Boyle interested Harris in the archaeological remains of the Indians of Ontario. (31) The first notice that I have found of this interest was in 1890 when the Canadian Institute obtained from Rev. Théophile Laboreau (1837-1908) some relics of the early French days dug from an Indian grave near Penetanguishene.
Dean Harris, of St. Catharines, an authority on such matters, thinks it probable that they were sent to Canada during the regime of Cardinal Richelieu. (32)
Harris had a larger than average clerical library and his included books on ethnology and Canadian Catholic history. The first published fruits of his reading and his conversations with experts in these fields was an article "The Indian Missions of Western Canada" that appeared in 1892. (33) The title needs a word of explanation. Ignoring the entry of Manitoba into Confederation and recalling his pre-Confederation postal address, "Toronto, Canada West," Harris passed up plain "Ontario" and used "Western Canada." He expanded this article into the book, History of the Early Missions in Western Canada, Toronto, 1893. In the preface he described it as
a beginning and [it] will, I trust, be an incentive to others who have time and talent to lend their aid in gathering material for the Ecclesiastical History of this Province. (34)
We can only regret that his invitation was not accepted and that the ecclesiastical history of this Province has still to be written. Two years later, just before the 25th anniversary of his ordination, he published The Catholic Church in the Niagara Peninsula, 1626-1895.
Harris was now at the peak of his pastoral career, an orator who was called upon for special sermons, (35) the leader of Catholic works in the Niagara Peninsula, (36) and at the same time continuing to participate in many other activities of the Archdiocese of Toronto. (37) He was a delegate to the Pan-American Congress of Religion and Education held at Toronto, July 1895, and read a paper on "The Mission Work of the Catholic Church in Western Ontario." The Buffalo Historical Society invited him to read a paper at their meeting of March 23, 1896, and in the same year he was a delegate to the Irish National Convention in Dublin. In 1898 J. Castell Hopkins (1864-1923) asked him for an article on the Catholic Church in Ontario for his Canada: An Encyclopedia of the Country. As the century drew to a close the strain of administering a large parish, the burden of outside engagements, and his efforts to do some writing took their toll on Harris' health. A division among the people of his parish (38) 38 led to his resignation on April 26, 1901. (39)
Harris left St. Catharines in the first week of June and, obtaining leave from the Archdiocese of Toronto, travelled widely during the next few years. In a book based on articles contributed to the Toronto Mail and Empire he described himself as:
an exile from my own land, driven to the South by a northern specialist. (40)
During these years he kept up his love of learning.
While I resided in Guatemala City I was a daily visitor to the library of the university, where are shelved many of the books carried away from the monasteries when the property of the Church was secularized in Guatemala. (41)
In 1905 Harris settled down in Salt Lake City as editor of the Intermountain Catholic. The masthead of this newspaper did not carry the name of its editor and there are no official records for the next seven years of his life. (42) In 1909 he published The Catholic Church in Utah. A large part of this book is a translation into English of the Diario or Journal of the Franciscan priests Francisco Atanasio Dominiguez and Silvestre Velez de Escalante (fl. 1668-1679) who entered Utah in 1675-76. With the approach of the American Bi-Centennial this translation is attracting interest in that State. (43) While in Salt Lake City he contributed three articles to the Catholic Encyclopedia and in 1908 he published another travel book, By Path and Trail. After his history of the Catholic Church in Utah appeared, Harris resigned as editor of the local Catholic newspaper but remained in the diocese as chaplain of St. Ann's Orphanage until 1910 and for some months more in the same capacity at Judge Mercy Hospital.
He was now an aging man whose thoughts went back to his first book. In 1912 he published a new edition with a new title, Pioneers of the Cross in Canada. He had been away from Toronto for eleven years and now at the urging of Msgr. Martin Whelan (1867-1935) then rector of St. Michael's Cathedral, he took an appointment as chaplain of St. John's Industrial School on Jan. 18, 1913. He resigned as chaplain on April 16, 1921, but remained in residence at the school until his death on March 5, 1923. (44) He was buried in Mount Hope Cemetery, Toronto. On Oct. 29, 1932, his remains were removed to St. Augustine's Cemetery on the grounds of St. Augustine's Seminary, Scarborough.
The chaplaincy at St. John's School gave Harris leisure for writing. A contemporary Catholic writer, Thomas O'Hagan, was of the opinion that Harris' best writing was done in his travel books.
In his descriptive writing the Dean is most happy. Here he gives proof of the accuracy of his observation. We must confess that we have rarely come across a finer bit of descriptive characterization than the following "certificate of character" which our author gives that little semi-tropical beast of burden, the burro, and which gives title to one of the chapters in By Path and Trail: The burro is not as Sunday School books picture him, the clown and puppet of domestic beasts. He is the imperturbable philosopher of the animal kingdom, the wisest thing in his own sphere of existence, and the best and truest friend of mountaineers. He is a stoic among fatalists, a reliable staff in emergencies, and an anchor of hope in dangerous places. Like the Champion of the prize ring, Joe Gans, or the sporting editor's 'King of the diamond turf', Cy Young, the donkey 'neither drinks nor smokes, nor chews tobacco'; in a word, he's a brick. (45)
One historical reviewer was less appreciative of Harris' style:
The popular narrative is set in florid descriptions of natural scenery... In spite of repetitions and of an irritating peculiarity of style which seeks to provide for almost every noun a superlative qualification, the book possesses interest which belong to sincerity and enthusiasm. (46)
Harris also offended historians by never compiling an index for his books and offering either a short bibliography or none at all. The weaknesses of his historical writings were due to an excessive reliance on his memory and to his lack of a thorough training in research which would have made him more critical in his use of sources and more precise in the presentation of his narrative.
Harris was aware of his limitations as a historian and he sought guidance from well-known authorities. The acknowledgments in the preface of his first book show that he sought help from the beginning.
In the collection of material for this volume I have received valuable help from Father Jones, of St. Mary's College, Montreal; Father Rouxel, of the Seminary of St. Sulpice; Mr. J.H. Coyne, St. Thomas; Mr. James Bain, of the Toronto Library, and Mr. John Henderson, M.A., of this city. (47)
One of his travel books pictures him as a typical modern tourist.
I remember well the day I came down from the Sieretta mountains and was passing on foot through the little town of Aguas Coloradas, the church of which was well worth seeing. I had my camera and the field glasses hanging from my shoulders, some few samples in a canvas bag, was wearing a suit of rough khaki and was not altogether the figure for the inside of a church. (48)
Another book shows that he did not cease to travel after his return to Toronto. (49)
From the first years of his priestly life Harris took an active part in community affairs. At Newmarket he impressed people with the value of the Public Library, lectured for the Mechanics' Institute, and was active in the Association of Mechanics' Institutes of Ontario where he served on the executive and was President in 1886. (50) At the time of his death he was President of the Ontario Archaeological Association. There were three public dinners that he always attended: the St. Andrew Society, the St. George Society, and the St. Patrick's Society. (51) One cause he never espoused was that of total abstinence.
Harris made friends
easily and one of the obituaries written at the time
of his death gave as the secret of his widespread friendships, "his
unfailing
kindness and courtesy." (52)
Another added:
Harris lived in an age
when the personal magnetism of the orator and
the author was a source of influence. In his historical books he met a
need of
his time, recapturing in a romantic and appealing way the lives of the
natives
and the first missionaries to Canada. His Prehistoric Man reacts
to the newly
popularized teachings on evolution and his Essays in Occultism,
Spiritism,
and Demonology show him to be a man attuned to the needs of his
time. But
he does not seem to mean very much to later generations and neither the
New
Catholic Encyclopedia nor the Encyclopedia Canadiana devote
an article to
his life and writings. Perhaps the judgment of these editors is
correct;
nevertheless, when the Ecclesiastical History of Ontario that he
envisioned
is written his life will have an honorable place in its pages as a
parish priest
ahead of his time in the
handling of parish finances, in ecumenical matters, as
a community leader, and his writings will present him as a pioneer in
adult
education. Let
us bring this paper
to a close by quoting the thoughtful words of his
Presbyterian friend:
The dead priest, scholar, traveler, friend, now lies "in the pomp of eternal silence." But his memory leaves no sting. Protestants and Catholics alike will follow him to the tomb. The light of love he kindled in many a heart and home will still bum on and although that kindly sun has set, the afterglow is rich and radiant to many an unforgetting heart like mine. (54)
BIBLIOGRAPHY MANUSCRIPTS April 29, 1866. "The Refugee." In St.
Michael's Literary Association, St. Michael's College,
Toronto: Speeches, Essays, Poems, Debates, 1858-1868, pp.
161-70. Manuscript in the Archives of the University of St. Michael's
College. June 1884. Autograph Letter
Signed. 1 page. This letter was written on a leaf torn out of
the pew rent book, pp. 103-104. Manuscript in the Archives of St. John
Chrysostom Parish, Newmarket, Ontario. October 2, 1885. Autograph Letter
Signed. 1 page. To the Hon. Col. Charles Clarke, Elora,
Ontario, supporting the application of David Boyle for a position.
Microfilm of the Colonel Charles Clarke Papers in the Archives of
Ontario. 1894-1903? Travel Notes and
Autograph Album. 210 p. Autographs on pp. 1-27, dated
1894-95, travel notes written in pencil with p. 168 dated Dec. 1902.
MS.Misc.l2mo.2 in the Library of the University of St. Michael's
College,
Toronto. 1900-1907? Notes of Foreign
Travel. 388 p. This volume is made up of several notebooks
bound together. Inside the front cover is a bookplate signed : W.R.
HARRIS. MS.Misc.l2mo.1 in the Library of the University of St.
Michael's
College, Toronto. BOOKS AND ARTICLES 1892. "Sketch of the Early
Missions in Western Canada." In Jubilee Volume, 1842-1892, the
Archdiocese of Toronto and Archbishop Walsh. Toronto, Geo.
T. DIXON, 1892, pp. 1-36. 1893. History of the
Early Missions in Western Canada. Toronto, Hunter, Rose and
Co., 1893, vii, 339p. 1894. "The Mound Builders and
Copper Workers." In The Carmelite Review. 2 (April
1894), pp. 86-87; (May 1894), pp. 114-16. "The Attiwindarons - A
Forgotten People." In The Carmelite Review. 2 (June
1894), pp. 130-31; (July 1894), pp. 153-56. "A Valiant Priest"
(Father Joseph de la Roche Dallion, Recollet). In The
Carmelite Review. 2 (Aug. 1894), pp. 178-81. 1895. "The Jesuits and the
Neutrals." In The Carmelite Review. 3 (Jan. 1895), pp. 7-9;
(Feb. 1895), pp. 53-55; (Mar. 1895), pp. 63-65. "Father Hennepin." In The
Carmelite Review. 3 (Mar. 1895), pp. 75-77; (April
1895), pp. 107-08. "The Priest and the
Explorer." In The Carmelite Review. 3 (May 1895), pp.
124-25; (June 1895), pp. 159-61. The Catholic
Church in the Niagara Peninsula, 1626-1895. Toronto, William
BRIGGS, 1895. 352 p., illus. 1896. "A Forgotten People:
The Flint Workers." In Buffalo Historical Society.
Publications. 4 (1896), pp. 227-44. 1898. "The Catholic Church in
Ontario." In J.C. HOPKINS : Canada, An Encyclopedia of the
Country. Toronto, 1898-1900. v. 2, pp. 452-66. 1900. "The Flint Workers : A
Forgotten People." In Archaeological Report. 12 (1900),
pp. 25-36. "Our Own Land." [n.p.,
n.d.] 4 p. Speech delivered at the "Old Boys" Meeting
at Beamsville, Ontario, Monday, Sept. 3, 1900. 1903. "The Caribs of Guiana
and the West Indies." In Archaeological Report. 15
(1903), pp. 139-145. 1905. Days and Nights in
the Tropics. Toronto, Morang & Co., Ltd., 1905. xi, 230 p.,
plates. Days and Nights in
the Tropics. Microfilm reprint. [Louisville, Louisville
Microfilms, 1966] 1 reel. 35 mm. (Travel Literature. Series 1: The
Americas.
Part 1: Mexico. Reel 36, no. 98). 1907. "Mormons, or the Church
of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints." In the Catholic
Encyclopedia. New York, 1907, Vol. 10, pp. 570-74. "Salt Lake, Diocese of
(Lacus Saisis)." In the Catholic Encyclopedia. New
York, 1907, Vol. 13, pp.404-05. "Utah, the
Thirty-Second State." In the Catholic Encyclopedia. New
York,
1907, Vol. 15, pp. 238-41. 1908. By Path and Trail.
Chicago, Chicago Newspaper Union, 1908. xi, 225 p., 8
plates. By Path and Trail [by]
Oswald CRAWFORD [pseud.] [Salt Lake City] The
Press of the "Intermountain Catholic," 1908. xi, 225 p., 8 plates. 1909. The Catholic
Church in Utah, including An Exposition of Catholic Faith by
Bishop Scanlan. A Review of Spanish and Missionary Explorations, Tribal
Divisions, Names and Regional Habitats of the pre-European Tribes. The
Journal of the Franciscan Explorers and Discoverers of Utah Lake. The
Trailing of the Priests from Santa Fe, N.M., with Map of Route,
Illustrations and Delimitations of the Great Basin. Salt Lake City,
Intermountain Catholic Press, 1909. iii, 350p., illus. 1912. Pioneers of the
Cross in Canada. Toronto, McClelland & Goodchild, Ltd.; St.
Louis, B. Herder, 1912. 240 p., illus. 2d ed. with an introduction by
Thomas O'Hagan. Toronto, McClelland & Stewart, 1930. vii, 240 p.,
illus. 1913. "Primitive Civilization
of the American Indian." In Archaeological Report. 25
(1913), pp. 22-33. 1914. The Pre-Christian
Cross." In Archaeological Report. 26 (1914), pp. 26-43.
Reprinted from the Archaeological Report. Toronto, 1914. 20
p. "Notes of Foreign
Travel: Chi-Chin-Itz, the Phantom City." In Saint Joseph
Lilies. 3 (Sept. 1914), pp. 10-17. "Notes of Foreign
Travel: Palenque in the Twilight." In Saint Joseph Lilies. 3
(Dec. 1914) pp. 55-65. 1915. "Practice of Medicine
and Surgery by the Canadian Tribes in Champlain's
Time." In Archaeological Report. 27 (1915), pp. 35-37.
Reprinted from the
Archaeological RepoRt. Toronto, 1915. 22p. "Ode To Health." (Poem)
In Niagara Rainbow. 22 (Jas. 1915), p. 12. "Invocation to
Contement." (Poem) In Niagara Rainbow. 22 (April 1915), p.
106. "My Second Visit to St.
Pierre, Martinique." In The Year Book, St. Michael's
College, Toronto. 6 (1915), pp. 89-91. Travel-Talks. Chatham,
Ont., Con. E. Shea's Printing and Publishing House,
1915. xi, 282 p., plates. 1916. "The Ape Man." In Archaeological
Report. 28 (1916), pp. 49-62. Prehistoric Man in
America. Toronto, 1916. 115 p., illus. "Reprinted from The
Archaeological Reports." "The Poetry of Father
Dollard." (An Appreciation) In St. Joseph Lilies. 4 (Mar.
1916), pp. 11-23. Reprinted, n.p., n.d., 15 p. "The Essays and
Lectures of Dean O'Malley." (Book Review) In St. Joseph
Lilies. 5 (June 1916), pp. 43-46. "Dr. John Talbot
SMITH." In St. Joseph Lilies. 5 (Sept. 1916), pp. 16-23.
Reprinted, n.p., n.d. 8 p. "Dr. Thomas O'Hagan."
"Essays On Catholic Life." (Book Review) In St.
Joseph Lilies. 5 (Dec. 1916), pp. 43-49. Reprinted, n.p., n.d. 7 p. Preface in Theobald
SPETZ: The Catholic Church in Waterloo County. Toronto,
Catholic Register and Extension, 1916, pp. v-vi. 1917. "Earth's First Man." In
Archaeological Report. 29 (1917), pp. 59-77. Reprinted, n.p.,
n.d. 18 p. "The Catholic
Atmosphere of Shakespeare's Drama." In Loretto Rainbow. (Jan.
1917) Not seen. Reprinted, n.p., n.d. 13 p. "A Letter to the Minims
of Loretto Abbey." In Loretto Rainbow. 24 (July 1917,
p. 70. "Natural Wonders of the
Southwest." In Loretto Rainbow. (Oct. 1917) Not seen. 1918. "The Mystery of a Land
That Disappeared." In Archaeological Report. 30
1918), pp. 54-73. "Fools For the Sake of
Christ." In St. Joseph Lilies. 6 (Mar. 1918), pp. 21-26;
7 (June 1918), pp. 70-75; (Sept. 1918), pp. 6-13. 1919. Essays in
Occultism, Spiritism, and Demonology. St. Louis, B. Herder;
Toronto,
McClelland, Goodchild & Stewart, 1919. vi, 181 p. "The Men Who Broke the
Trail to Hudson Bay." In Archaeological Report. 31
(1919), pp. 88-89. "St. Joseph's College
Museum." In St. Joseph Lilies. 8 (Dec. 1919), pp. 73-77. 1920. The Cross-Bearers
of the Saguenay. London and Toronto, J.M. Dent & Sons,
1920. 202 p., illus. "Étienne
Brulé, The Man Who Broke the Trail to Georgian Bay." In Archaeological
Report. 32 (1920), pp. 38-47. "Valuable Contribution
to the Museum." In St. Joseph Lilies. 9 (June 1920) p.
62. 1921. Tadoussac and Its
Indian Chapel. n.p., n.d. 66 p., illus. On cover: 1617-1921.
"Where They Laid Their Beloved to Rest." In St. Joseph Lilies. 10
(June 1921),
pp. 37-42; (Sept. 1921), pp. 14-21. 1922. "Parent Lands of Our
Algonquins and Hurons." In Archaeological Report. 33
(1922), pp. 41-54. "Mystery of a
Disappearing People." In St. Joseph Lilies. 11 (Dec. 1922)
pp.
41-56. "A Dear And Well
Beloved Priest." (Golden Jubilee of Rev. Edmund Murray,
C.S.B., 1844-1925). In The Year Book, St. Michael's College,
Toronto. 13
(1922), pp. 19-20. Response to the Toast
"The Clergy" at the centennial dinner of St. Paul's
Parish, Toronto, Monday, Nov. 13, 1922. In Edward KELLY: The Story
of
St. Paul's Parish, Toronto, 1822-1922. Toronto, 1923, pp. 304-305. 1923. "Étienne
Brulé, The Man Who Broke the Trail to Georgian Bay." In St.
Joseph
Lilies. 12 (Jan. 1923), pp. 64-76. Undated, after 1919. Here and There in
Mexico. Chatham, Ont., Con. E. Shea Printing and Publishing
House. 178p.
1. I would like to acknowledge the assistance
given me in the preparation of
this paper by Mrs. Margaret McGrath of the University of St. Michael's
College
Library, Rev. James McGivern, S.J., Archivist for the Archdiocese of
Toronto, the
staffs of the Archives of Ontario, the Legislative Library of the
Province of Ontario,
the Metropolitan Toronto Central Library, and the United Church of
Canada
Archives.
2. Manuscript of 75 typed pages with corrections
and additions in longhand.
In the Edith and Lorne Pierce Collection of Canadian Literary
Manuscripts, Douglas
Library, Queen's University, Kingston.
3. Archives of the Archdiocese of Toronto.
4. George MacLean ROSE: A Cyclopedia of
Canadian Biography. Toronto,
1888, pp. 224-25. This has the fullest account of Harris' work as a
parish priest.
Henry James MORGAN: The
Canadian Men and Women of the Time. Toronto, 1898,
pp. 442-43: 21 ed., 1912, pp. 5-6. Georgina Pell CURTIS The American Catholic
Who's Who. St. Louis, 1911, pp. 274-75. The Catholic Encyclopedia
and Its Makers.
New York, 1917, p. 73. Jesse Edgar MIDDLETON: The Municipality of Toronto.
Toronto, 1923, v.2, p. 18. Encyclopedia of Canada. Toronto,
1936, v. 3, p. 116.
Walter ROMIG: The
Guide to Catholic Literature. Detroit, 1940, pp. 497-98.
William Stewart WALLACE : Dictionary of Canadian
Biography. Toronto, 1945,
v. 1, p. 264. Vernon Blair RHODENIZER: Canadian Literature in
English.
Montreal, 1965, p. 401. A full list of Harris' books is given in the National
Union
Catalog, Pre-1956 Imprints. London, 1972, v. 232, pp. 191-92.
5. Personal interviews with: Msgr. Edward
Brennan, Dec. 9, 1973; Msgr.
John Corrigan, Nov. 17, 1973; Msgr. William Davis, Jan. 3, 1974; Rev.
Robert
Miller, Oct. 19, 1973; Rev. John O'Reilly, Nov. 17, 1973; and Rev.
Francis
Pennylegion, Nov. 17, 1973. Letters from: Brother Cyril Powers, FSC,
Jan. 16, 1974;
Rev. Walter Forgach, Dec. 8 & 21, 1973; Msgr. Athol Murray, Jan. 26
& May 28,
1974; Rev. Michael Oliver, CSB, Oct. 16 & 24, 1973. These
reminiscences cover
only the last years of Harris' life, but those of Msgrs. Brennan.and
Murray give some
glimpses of his earlier years because their fathers were friends of
Dean Harris.
6. Interviews with Rev. Robert Miller and Rev.
John O'Reilly.
7. G.M. ROSE: Cyclopedia of
Canadian Biography, p. 224.
8. Archives of the Archdiocese of Toronto.
9. Letters to the author from St. Mary's
Cathedral, St. Finbarr, St. Patrick,
and Sts. Peter and Paul Parishes.
10. Letter to the author, Mar. 29, 1974.
11. "Obituary: Very Reverend Dean HARRIS" in Archaeological
Report 34
(1923). U. 140.
12. Treasurer's Account Books, 1864-65, in the
Archives of the University of
St. Michael's College, Toronto.
13. Toronto Daily
Star, Apr. 11, 1923. This information was supplied by
Brother Cyril Powers, FSC, in his letter to the author, Jan. 16, 1974.
14. Dictionary of
American Biography. New York, 1932, v. 5, pp. 195-96.
Mrs. William D. McLean of Beckley, West Virginia, is researching this
possible
relationship.
15. Brother Prudent MacDonald, FSC, letter to
the author, Jan. 28, 1974.
16. Treasurer's Account Books, 1864-66, in the
Archives of the University of
St. Michael's College. Verified in the Archives of the Archdiocese of
Toronto.
17. Abbé Lionel LÉVEILLÉ,
Archivist of the College, letter to the author, Jan.
11, 1974. See also Wilfrid LEBON: 18. Interview with Rev. Robert Miller, Oct. 19,
1973.
19. Msgr. Athol Murray, letter to the author,
Jan. 26, 1974. See also R.S.
HUNTER: Rowing in Canada
Since 1848. Hamilton, 1933, p. 21.
20. Register of Ordinations, in the Archives of
the Archdiocese of Toronto. The
date usually given is June 21st.
21. Canadian
Freeman, Sept. 15, 1870.
22. Rev. Paul Switalski, pastor of St. James
Parish, Colgan, letter to the author,
Jan. 30, 1974.
23. Rev. T.J. McManus, pastor of St. Joseph's
Parish, Beaverton, letter to the
author, Mar. 11, 1974. St. Malachy's Church, Brock Township, is now
attended from
Beaverton.
24. Msgr. Pearce Lacey, rector of St. Michael's
Cathedral, Toronto, letter to
the author, Dec. 10, 1973.
25. Rev. Walter Forgach, pastor of St. John
Chrysostom Parish, Newmarket,
letter to the author, Dec. 8, 1973.
26. Cf. List
of Manuscripts in the Bibliography.
27. Msgr. M.H. Delaney, rector of St.
Catherine's Cathedral, St. Catharines,
letter to the author, Jan. 31, 1974.
28. Catholic Weekly
Review, Feb. 16, 1889.
29. Ibid., Nov.
17, 1888.
30. ARCHIVES of ONTARIO. Cf. List
of Manuscripts in the Bibliography.
31. Other mentors of Harris in this field were
John Henderson (1846- ),
Principal of St. Catharines C.I., and Frank Hayward Severance
(1856-1931),
Secretary of the Buffalo Historical Society.
32. Catholic Weekly
Review, May 17, 1890.
33. In the Jubilee Volume,
1842-1892, the Archdiocese of Toronto and
Archbishop Walsh. Toronto, 1892, pp. 1-36. Harris' contribution
dealt with the years
1615-1760.
34. p. v.
35. E.g.
He
preached at the opening of St. Helen's Church, Toronto. Catholic
Weekly Review, June 1, 1889.
36. The only mention of Harris in the Annual Reports of
the Canadian Catholic
Historical Association records his lead-off contribution to the
building fund of a new
retreat house at the Shrine of Our Lady of Peace, Niagara Falls,
Ontario, v.21 (1954),
p. 58. His letter accompanying his donation, May 30, 1890, was
published in The
Carmelite Review, 1 (1893), p. 46.
37. E.g.
The
organization meeting of The Catholic Truth Society. Catholic
Weekly Review, Jan. 18, 1890.
38. Interview with Msgr. Edward Brennan. His
father was a member of the
deputation seeking to retain Harris as pastor.
39. ARCHIVES OF THE ARCHDIOCESE OF TORONTO.
40. Days
and Nights
in the Tropics, p. 17. There is in the Archives of the
Archdiocese of Toronto a letter from Dr. J. Sheehan, 31 Church Street,
St.
Catharines, May 23, 1901, advising "change in your conditions and
surroundings is
imperative."
41. Days and Nights
in the Tropics, p. 171.
42. Very Rev. John J. Hedderman, letter to the
author, Feb. 4, 1974.
43. Ibid. 44. BrotherCyril Powers, FSC, letter to the
author, Jan. 16, 1974.
45. Thomas O'HAGAN: Dean Harris.
Appreciation, pp. 6-7. Unpublished
manuscript in the Edith and Lome Pierce Collection of Canadian Literary
Manuscripts, Douglas Library, Queen's University, Kingston.
46. W.P.M. KENNEDY, Review of "The
Cross-Bearers of the Saguenay" in
the Canadian
Historical Review. 2 (1921) p. 79.
47. History of the
Early Missions in Western Canada, p. vi.
48. Travel-Talks,
p. 139.
49. Here and There
in Mexico, p. 163.
50. Annual Reports and Minute Books of the
Association of Mechanics'
Institutes of Ontario. In the ARCHIVES OF ONTARIO.
51. Interview with Msgr. Edward Brennan.
52. "An Old Friend" [pseud.]: "The Late Dean
Harris" in The Year
Book of
St.
Michael's College, Toronto. 14 (1923) p. 19. 53. Rev. Michael CLINE, "Death of the Very Rev.
Dean Harris" in St.
Joseph
Lilies. 11 (Mar. 1923) p. 13. 54. R.E. KNOWLES, "Light of Love He Kindled In
Many Hearts Still Burns"
in the Toronto Daily
Star, Tuesday, Mar. 6, 1923, p. 17.